What is the Difference Between a Heat Pump and a Furnace?

by Subodha Senevirathne

Regarding heating your home, two of the most popular options are heat pumps and furnaces. While both serve the same fundamental purpose—keeping your home warm—they operate in entirely different ways. A heat pump works by transferring heat from the outside air or ground, making it an energy-efficient choice, while a furnace generates heat by burning fuel or using electricity, making it a powerful option in colder climates.

Choosing between a heat pump and a furnace depends on several factors, including climate, efficiency, cost, and environmental impact. Understanding these differences can help homeowners make an informed decision that best suits their heating needs. Let's compare heat pumps and furnaces in terms of how they work, energy efficiency, cost, cold-weather performance, lifespan, and environmental impact, helping you decide which system is right for you.

1. How Heat Pumps and Furnaces Work

How a Heat Pump Works

A heat pump does not create heat; instead, it transfers heat from the outside air or ground into your home. This process is similar to how an air conditioner works but in reverse.

  • In the winter, it extracts heat from the outside air (even in cold temperatures) and moves it indoors.

  • In the summer, it functions as an air conditioner by removing heat from inside and releasing it outdoors.

There are two main types of heat pumps:

  • Air-source heat pumps (extract heat from the air).

  • Ground-source (geothermal) heat pumps (extract heat from the ground).

How a Furnace Works

A furnace generates heat by burning fuel (natural gas, propane, or oil) or using electricity. This heat is then distributed through ducts via a blower fan.

  • Gas furnaces are the most common type and use a heat exchanger to warm the air.

  • Electric furnaces use heating elements similar to space heaters.

Unlike heat pumps, furnaces only provide heating and do not function as cooling systems.

2. Energy Efficiency: Heat Pump vs. Furnace

One of the biggest differences between a heat pump and a furnace is energy efficiency.

✅ Heat Pumps Are More Efficient

  • Heat pumps are up to 3-4 times more efficient than furnaces because they move heat rather than generate it.

  • The coefficient of Performance (COP) for heat pumps can be 300% or higher, meaning they deliver three times as much heat as the electricity they consume.

  • Best for moderate climates where temperatures don’t drop below freezing frequently.

✅ Furnaces Are Less Efficient but More Reliable in Cold Weather

  • Gas furnaces typically have 80-98% efficiency (also known as AFUE rating).

  • Furnaces maintain consistent heating performance even in sub-zero temperatures.

Winner: Heat pumps are generally more energy-efficient, but in extreme cold, furnaces may be more practical.

3. Cost Comparison: Installation & Operating Costs

Upfront Installation Costs

System Average Cost (Including Installation)
Heat Pump $4,000 – $10,000
Gas Furnace $3,000 – $7,000
Electric Furnace $1,500 – $5,500

  • Heat pumps tend to cost more upfront due to their dual functionality (heating and cooling).

  • Furnaces, especially gas models, can be cheaper to install if gas lines are already in place.

Operating Costs

  • Heat pumps are cheaper to operate in areas where electricity is affordable.

  • Gas furnaces can be cheaper in places where natural gas is inexpensive.

  • Electric furnaces are the most expensive to run due to high electricity consumption.

Winner: Heat pumps save more money in the long run, but furnaces have a lower initial cost.

4. Performance in Cold Weather

Heat Pumps in Cold Weather

  • It works well in temperatures above 30°F (-1°C).

  • Lose efficiency as temperatures drop below freezing.

  • Cold-climate heat pumps (CCHPs) can work efficiently down to -15°F (-26°C).

Furnaces in Cold Weather

  • Perform better in freezing temperatures.

  • Provide consistent, strong heat output.

  • More reliable in extreme cold than heat pumps.

Winner: Furnaces are better for extremely cold regions, while heat pumps work well in moderate climates.

5. Environmental Impact

Heat Pumps Are More Eco-Friendly

  • Use electricity instead of burning fossil fuels.

  • It can be powered by solar panels for 100% clean energy.

  • Reduce carbon emissions compared to furnaces.

Furnaces Have a Higher Carbon Footprint

  • Gas furnaces emit carbon dioxide (CO₂), a greenhouse gas.

  • Oil furnaces are even less environmentally friendly.

  • Electric furnaces are cleaner but costly to operate.

Winner: Heat pumps are the better choice for sustainability.

6. Lifespan & Maintenance

Feature Heat Pump Furnace
Lifespan 10-15 years 15-20 years
Maintenance Needs more frequent servicing Requires maintenance but less.

  • Heat pumps run year-round (for heating & cooling), so they wear out faster.

  • Furnaces last longer because they’re used only in winter.

  • Gas furnaces need regular safety checks for carbon monoxide leaks.

Winner: Furnaces last longer, but heat pumps require less fuel-based maintenance.

7. Which One is Right for You?

Factor Heat Pump Furnace
Climate Best for mild winters Best for cold climates
Energy Efficiency More efficient Less efficient
Heating Power Works well above freezing Strong heat output in extreme cold
Cooling Ability Yes, also works as an AC No, heating only
Upfront Cost Higher Lower
Operating Cost Lower in electric-dominant regions Lower if natural gas is cheap
Lifespan 10-15 years 15-20 years
Environmental Impact Low (electric-powered) High (burns fossil fuels)

 

So, which is better: a heat pump or a furnace? The answer depends on your climate, budget, and efficiency needs.

✅ Choose a Heat Pump If:

  • You live in a mild or moderate climate (above 30°F).

  • You want energy efficiency and lower bills.

  • You need both heating and cooling in one system.

  • You prefer an eco-friendly solution.

✅ Choose a Furnace If:

  • You live in a cold climate where winters are harsh.

  • You need reliable heating in sub-zero temperatures.

  • You have access to low-cost natural gas.

  • You want a system that lasts longer.

Deciding between a heat pump and a furnace ultimately comes down to your climate, energy efficiency needs, budget, and environmental considerations.

  • If you live in a mild or moderate climate, a heat pump is a more energy-efficient and cost-effective option that provides both heating and cooling.

  • If you reside in a cold climate with harsh winters, a furnace is the better choice, offering reliable and powerful heating even in freezing temperatures.

  • For homeowners in extreme climates, a dual-fuel system (heat pump + furnace) can provide optimal efficiency and comfort year-round.

In the long run, both systems have their advantages, but choosing the right one can help you save money and energy, and reduce your carbon footprint. Before making a decision, consider installation costs, operating expenses, and long-term efficiency to ensure the best heating solution for your home.

Back to News