Can I Replace My Existing Furnace or AC with a Heat Pump?

by Subodha Senevirathne

Yes, you can replace your existing furnace or air conditioner with a heat pump, but there are several factors to consider before making the switch. Heat pumps offer both heating and cooling in one system, making them an efficient alternative to traditional HVAC setups. Below are key aspects to evaluate when replacing your furnace or AC with a heat pump.

1. Understanding How a Heat Pump Works

Unlike a furnace that generates heat by burning fuel or using electric resistance, a heat pump transfers heat from the outside air (or ground) into your home during winter. It does the reverse in summer to provide cooling. This dual function makes heat pumps an excellent replacement for both furnaces and air conditioners.

2. Can a Heat Pump Fully Replace a Furnace?

Yes, but it depends on your climate.

If You Live in a Mild or Moderate Climate (Like Texas or Southern U.S.)

  • A heat pump can entirely replace your furnace since it provides efficient heating and cooling.
  • You won’t need a backup heating source.

If You Live in a Colder Climate (Like Ontario or Northern U.S.)

  • In temperatures below -15°C (5°F), some heat pumps struggle to extract enough heat from the air.
  • You may need a hybrid system, where a heat pump works alongside a furnace or electric backup heater for extreme cold.
  • Cold-climate heat pumps (CCHPs) are designed to work efficiently in freezing temperatures and can be a full replacement in many cases.

3. Can a Heat Pump Replace Just My AC?

Yes! If you already have a furnace but want to replace your air conditioner, a heat pump is a great choice.

  • In summer, a heat pump works just like an air conditioner, cooling your home efficiently.
  • In winter, instead of sitting idle like an AC, it provides heating—so you get extra functionality for a similar price.
  • If your furnace is still in good shape, you can install a heat pump for cooling while keeping the furnace for heating in extreme cold.

4. Will My Existing Ductwork Work with a Heat Pump?

  • If you have a central air system, you can usually install a heat pump without major ductwork changes.
  • If you don’t have ducts, you may need a ductless mini-split heat pump, which provides zoned heating and cooling without requiring ductwork.

5. Is a Heat Pump Cost-Effective Compared to a Furnace?

Initial Cost

  • Heat pumps can have a higher upfront cost than just replacing a furnace or AC.
  • However, they save money in the long run due to their energy efficiency.

Energy Savings

  • Heat pumps are 3-4 times more efficient than electric furnaces and cheaper to run than gas furnaces in areas with mild winters.
  • If electricity rates are high, a gas furnace might still be cheaper for heating in some regions.

Government Incentives & Rebates

  • Many areas offer rebates and tax credits for switching to heat pumps, which helps offset the cost.

6. When Is It a Good Idea to Replace a Furnace or AC with a Heat Pump?

  • If your furnace or AC is old (10-15+ years) and needs replacing soon.
  • If you live in a region with mild winters.
  • If you want to reduce energy bills & carbon footprint.
  • If your home already has central ductwork.
  • Are there local rebates or incentives for heat pumps?

Should You Replace Your Furnace or AC with a Heat Pump?

Replacing your furnace or air conditioner with a heat pump can be a smart decision, but whether it’s the right choice depends on several factors, including your climate, energy costs, and existing HVAC setup.

You SHOULD Replace Your Furnace or AC with a Heat Pump If:

✔ You live in a moderate or mild climate (like Texas or the southern U.S.) where a heat pump can provide efficient heating and cooling year-round.
✔ Your current AC is old—a heat pump can replace it while also giving you heating in winter.
✔ You want to lower energy bills—heat pumps are more energy-efficient than traditional furnaces and air conditioners.
✔ You’re looking for an eco-friendly option—heat pumps reduce carbon emissions compared to gas furnaces.
✔ There are rebates or tax incentives in your area that can help lower the upfront cost.

Is a Heat Pump Right for You?

  • If you live in a warm or moderate climate → A heat pump can fully replace both your furnace and AC.
  • If you live in a cold climate →  A heat pump can replace your AC and work alongside your furnace in winter.
  • If you’re replacing just your AC → A heat pump is a better upgrade than a traditional air conditioner because it also provides heating.

Before making a decision, check for local rebates, electricity rates, and heating needs to ensure a heat pump is the best investment for your home.

Back to News